Client Testimonials

I’m so lucky to have such wonderful clients who would take the time and write me a testimonial. Thank you!

Additional letters/notes

Amy was the best agent we have every worked with.  We appreciated her patience, follow-up, anticipation of our needs and honesty. You are lucky to have her!  Richard and Michele W., Ft. Myers, FL

Wonderful service from start to finish.  Peter and Mary V., Highland, NY

Enjoyed working with Amy and lucked out in that she’s my new next door neighbor!  Karen H., Houston, TX

I have dealt with Amy in the past, she is knowledgeable, always professional.  I would not hesitate to use her services in the future.  Nathaniel D., Jupiter, FL

Amy truly went above & beyond for me. I have dealt with several realtors in my lifetime, but she was by far the best I’ve ever used. She sold my duplex on KCB before it even was officially listed, and worked hard to get me in my new condo on KCB. Highly recommended.  Howard S., Haslett, MI

Amy was excellent from the beginning of our property search through closing.  Jennifer M. & Cary F., Duck Key, FL

Very impressed by professional attitude and attention to details. Good job.  John and Carolyn S.  Gwynedd Valley, PA and Key West, FL

Amy’s knowledge of the Middle Keys communities and established professional contacts, make her the obvious choice of which agent we wanted to work with.  After losing a few foreclosure bids/deals in Hawk’s Cay and Tranquility Bay, she went out and found us an unlisted property and made the deal get done. Great job!  Russell B. and Tonie D., Brentwood, TN

Amy is AWESOME! We have known and worked with Amy since 2010. She represented us when we bought our house and then when we sold it. She is so great to work with because she really knows the industry and the area inside and out. She comes across as low pressure which is really nice, but she really gets the job done! From the beginning I knew we could trust her. She got the deals done and to our satisfaction. On a personal note, she is just a really great person – warm, funny and caring. We really like her and consider her a friend. When we are ready to buy again in the Keys, we will definitely be calling Amy!!!  Brooke J., Huntingtown, MD

Amy & her team are top notch! Amy and her partner (husband) took us out in the heat of July 100 degrees our more searching for our “vacation” home now, retirement later. We didn’t find what we were looking for, but I enjoy getting weekly emails from her. Amy is very professional and dedicated to her search for us!! When we do find what we are looking for- Amy will be our person!!! Looking forward to working with her in the future!  Kathy T, Cincinnati, OH

Amy Puto was recommended to us by a local contractor when we finally decided to sell our vacant lot in Sombero (we’re from Chicago, IL). Amy’s expertise was invaluable in pricing and negotiating the sale of the lot. Amy even spoke with, and got, a not-so-nice neighboring homeowner to move his belongings from off of our vacant lot onto his own property! Amy’s use of DocuSign made the entire transaction virtual. We highly recommend Amy Puto for your real estate needs in the Keys.  Kevin K., Chicago, IL

My husband and I own some real estate in the Keys and we are always interested in how the real estate market is doing in that area. We have been subscribing to Amy Puto’s Weekly Market Report for a couple of years now in order to stay in the loop. She is SUPER thorough and has very up-to-date information included in her reports. She is extremely knowledgable. I highly recommend subscribing. I have passed her information along to as many people as I can, and of course I’m trying to convince all of my northern friends to subscribe and start scoping out their retirement and/or income properties! I am sure that in the event we need to buy or sell in the future, she is the one we will be calling. I wish all Realtors loved their jobs the way Amy loves hers!  Dana K., Michigan

Although I haven’t bought yet, Amy has been doing a great job keeping me abreast of the entire keys market conditions, listings, sales, pricing, etc. She has also responded personally to any questions I’ve had. When I’m ready to get more serious about buying, Amy will be my realtor. Don S., North Carolina

You are terrific and the most professional, prepared and attentive realtor I have ever dealt with. Should the need arise for me or any of my friends to look for property in the Keys, I will not hesitate to recommend you. Thanks again. Scott L., Miami, FL

Amy is calm and has a nice demeanor. Easy to work with!  Ken and Samantha M., St. Pete, FL

Simply outstanding!  Shannon and Dana M., Marathon, FL

Amy is the best real estate professional!  Brian and Misty R., Capron, IL

Amy is the best!  Ed M., Mashpee, MA

Amy was wonderful from start to finish.  She constantly made herself available by meeting with us, phone calls & email.  Amy went above & beyond throughout the process and even provided us with answers to all of our questions regarding utilities and other services.  She is a true gem and we look forward to working with her again.  Paul, Michael & Laura.  Hull, MA

Extremely pro-active as well as creative.  Always quickly answered queries and had time to meet in person.  Even showed listing on a Saturday.  Christopher P., Biscayne Park, FL

Amy is an excellent sales associate. Very professional, courteous and persistent!  She is an asset to your company. She gets the job done and sees it through.  Jerry and Debbie M., Mobile, AL

Hi Amy,   Tanya and I would like to thank you for the lovely gift basket you sent.  It was so thoughtful of you and we really appreciate all that you did to get the property sold. I must say you went above and beyond in all that you did, and we truly think you are a gifted person with integrity and a credit to the real estate profession.  We are still looking for a property in the Keys and we hope to deal with you again on our next purchase. Best regards, Giovanni and Tanya I., Whitestone, NY

Amy was very diligent and took care of our needs.  David D. and Theodore D., Davie, FL

Amy was an absolute pleasure to work with!  She took care of everything in a timely manner, answered our questions and concerns right away, and most importantly helped us find our dream home!  We couldn’t be happier with her service. She’s absolutely fabulous! Thanks Amy!  Bernie and Alina N., North Bay Village, FL

Amy has established an excellent website and keeps her buyers and sellers totally informed every week with listings of newly listed, under contract, closed properties.  If you are on her mailing list for her Friday updates, you need no other info. Amy is the best!  Her husband, Jerry, is also a great help.  Gene & Judith C., Fishersville, VA.

Amy is a pleasure to deal with and I would highly recommend her to anyone.  Paul R., Davie, FL

Amy is one of your biggest assets!  I heard that Amy was great. SHE IS!  Harold & Julie B., Dade City, FL

Amy did an excellent job. Thanks.  Paul S., Bellingham, WA

Amy is outstanding. She is always on top of our needs in looking for our home to purchase. She provided us the newest listings as soon as they hit the market and we made an offer on this one within a day or two and closed on it. Thanks Amy! You are terrific!  John & Aileen A., Ft. Lauderdale, FL

We can’t wait for the Friday email letter from Amy, even AFTER closing on our home!  We looked for the right property for several years and Amy was patient and always helpful during the lengthy search.  During the search, we grew to like and trust Amy and her husband, Jerry, and consider them friends. John & Sara, Bradenton, FL

Amy Puto is amazing! She was always available and responded to email immediately. She helped me close the deal and provided all the information to get settled. Clone Amy!  Melanie R., Rochester, MN

Amy Puto was exceptional!  She is very knowledgeable regarding the market in the Keys.  I felt she was very trustworthy, professional and most of all a friend.  If not for Amy I do not know that I would have found the property we are purchasing.  Joy C., Franklin, TN

Amy is an excellent agent.  Her weekly email is very helpful.  I will definitely use her in the future for my real estate needs.  Thanks again Amy!  Nat D.,  Tequesta, FL 

Amy was great to work with.  Never lost patience with me even after 1 million questions!  Chance R.,  Floyds Knobs, IN

Amy is as good as any sales person we have ever worked with! Friendly, professional, prepared and knowledgeable! It was a pleasure!  David & Jane S., Orlando, FL

Amy was terrific! As a businessman I’m not easy to work with. Amy is very patient and very professional. She kept me informed of every new listing allowing us to make quick and decisive decisions on making offers. Thank you Amy!  John & Aileen A., Ft. Lauderdale, FL (they purchased their 3rd property from me).

Amy was fantastic!  She answered all our questions promptly.  We had to pull out of a short sale, and we refused another offer. She cheerfully stuck with us until we found what we wanted.  James and Shana  G., Westfield, NJ

Leigh and I enjoyed working with you and are grateful for your role on a VERY successful team!!  You are very energetic and a true professional.  We wish you continued success. John and Leigh W., Northbrook, IL

Amy is a true professional in real estate.  She made this very easy for us.  Jim & Laura M., Kalkaska, MI

We were not the easiest buyers and so Amy had to work really hard for us.  She was always very professional and nice to be around.  She listened to us and showed us potential homes that fit our requests and now we own a perfect getaway.  I would definitely recommend going through Amy if you are looking for a home in the Keys.  Ken and Samantha M., St. Petersburg, FL

Excellent service from my first call until after closing.  Weekly update calls.  Amy gave excellent service even for such a small dollar purchase.  I will definitely use Amy for any future sales or purchases.  Rich M., Frontenac, MO

Amy was fantastic!  The Best!  Rick D., Knoxville, TN

Amy was professional, competent, timely, friendly, smart.  In short, it was one of the best experiences, perhaps the best, I’ve had buying or selling real estate.  Thank you!  William S., Miami, FL

Amy, We were surprised and delighted to receive your gift basket yesterday afternoon!  It’s been a pleasure working with you.  Besides just liking you, we’re impressed with your professional manner and handling of the sale of the condo on Coco Plum.  We wish you success,  Sara and Bill S., Miami,  FL

In my opinion, had we dealt with anyone but you, we would still be paying rent, rather than drinking vodka tonics by the pool.  Kent L., Marathon, FL

Amy, Been reading your newsletter for quite some time, thank you very much. It’s very helpful and as an owner of a condo in Lower Matecumbe, it’s full of great info and links I can use!  Don and Deb V., Islamorada, FL

Amy helped to price where it would sell. She was excellent!  Rob and Gloria L., Key West, FL

Dear Amy, Thank you for all you have done. We can now move on with our lives because of your work and efforts.  Not an easy ride, to be sure. Thank you for your tireless patience, good cheer and incredible work.  We will always be grateful.  All the very best, Bonnie & Michael K., Kensington, MD

Amy, thank you for all your hard work and dedication in finding us our new home away from home.  Keith and Lynn S., Hattiesburg,  MS

Amy went above and beyond to help us find our first home.  As first time homebuyers that encountered many problems (financing, property type and market conditions), we could not have become homeowners without her knowledge and passion.  Kent and Bridget L., Marathon, FL

We purchased our 2nd vacation rental property with Amy.   Amy did a great job in providing us info up-to-date and meeting with us promptly. Kudos Amy!  John and Aileen A., Ft. Lauderdale, FL

Amy was perhaps the best agent I have worked with in many years.  I feel that her website is one of the best in providing the info needed to help make a buying decision.  I look forward to working with her again real soon.  Richard W, N. Myrtle Beach, SC

Dear Amy,  Since we started looking for a new home in the keys, we have found your weekly report invaluable in narrowing our search. We found the perfect home thanks to you. Your patience was appreciated and your expertise in the keys real estate market was unmatched. Since we purchased our home, we continue to look forward to your weekly emails to keep us informed about what is happening in the keys.  Amy, you did a great job for us, and we thank you for all your help.  We could not have done it without you. Tom & Sherry H., Brant Beach, NJ

Your Weekly Report is the best and most informative piece of Real Estate info that comes out of the Keys and I can get it anywhere in the world…….Thanks!  Julian D., Cambridge UK

Your website and your weekly report has been a great asset to our office and has assisted us in contacting the agents involved in the transactions to establish correct data for our reports.  Thank you so much for sharing your knowledge and information with so many people.  I have personally referred a great number of people to you so they too can benefit from this vital information.  MaryAnne G., Marathon, FL

In a time when service and attention to detail are on the wane, your weekly emails are an excellent example of a customer first professional attitude.  Through these emails, I have grown to understand the real estate market in the Keys probably better than I do the market in my own back yard, over 1000 miles away. This information has made me and probably others more confident when it comes to making informed decisions about your market. Doug L., Waynesburg, PA

Hi Amy, Thanks for all the info on the Duck Key homes! Your professionalism is beyond the ordinary and common. All this information will be very helpful in making our decision about a new home in the Keys! Bud H., Canfield, OH

Fridays would not be the same without your weekly email report advising me about what is going on in the Middle Keys Real Estate Market.  It is my way of staying abreast of buying opportunities, in the various price ranges, especially utilizing your “what I would buy” categories, and quickly and easily reviewing the homes new on the market, and those pending, and those that have come back on the market.  The Newsletter enables me to keep my finger on the pulse in the Middle Keys, yet I am over 1500 miles away.  I also like receiving the interim emails when you spot a “deal” and it cannot (or will not) wait until Friday’s e-mailing.  David H., Oklahoma

My wife and I have purchased over a dozen properties in the last 20 years.  During this time we have worked with many different realtors and brokers in various parts of the country.  Amy has demonstrated the highest level of professionalism and dedicated follow up that clearly separates her from so many others.  Her commitment to the customer is not only exceptional, but sincere and she is always there to help provide recommendations and advice.  Most importantly, she knows the market and understands where to find good value.  Our experience with her is nothing short of exceptional and we recommend her to anyone that desires to buy or sell property in the Keys.  Bill R., West Palm Beach, FL

Your Weekly Market Report is something I love to receive, and wait to get it every Friday. I have been looking for a suitable place in the Keys, and because of the report, Marathon is where I have found some places to look at for my new home. The report allows me to see what I wanted and helps me find a place I can afford , price wise, without high pressure.  John “J.T” L.

Best regular synopsis of the market I have seen. I send it to my clients and customers.  Brian S., Marathon, FL

The best newsletter in the business!!!   Keeps us current on the real estate conditions in the Keys.  We look forward to getting it every Friday!   Sally and David M., Marathon, FL

The Weekly Market Report has been very informative for me with Marathon’s realty’s news.  It keeps me up to date with the changes of the market and it gives me an opportunity to be knowledgable of the markets availability.   Martha H., Miami, FL

My husband and I look forward to getting your weekly update every Friday.   It keeps us in touch with everything happening in the Marathon area.  We enjoy reviewing your professional recommendations and like your direct, matter of fact approach to selling real estate.   Your website is easy to use and a great marketing tool! Barbara R., West Palm Beach, FL

Amy is one of those individuals who doesn’t let details slide. She returns phone calls and emails faster than any Realtor I have ever worked with. She also listens to what you want as the customer and radiates values and genuine concern.   Her intellect and ability to understand our needs and desires make her outstanding in her field. Renee E. Green Bay, WI

Makes me feel like family! Dawn E., Bayside, NY

Your weekly report is very helpful. I recently sold an airplane to a doctor, he said he was going to use it to fly to Marathon and was looking for a condo to fly to. His name is Ron H. I gave him your name, phone number and e mail address. Good luck.  Gene C., Bradenton, FL

Amy did a great job! Dan and Susan F., Covington, KY

You are one of the most patient sales pro’s I know.  Lynn and I appreciate your efforts very much and when we find our home in Marathon that fits, you can be proud that you’ve made our lifelong dreams come true.   Keith and Lynn S., Hattiesburg, MS

Amy was very good in her communication and took care of my needs at the home that were over and beyond the responsibility of an agent.  She is to be commended for the quality of service and care.  Clarence S., Westchester, PA

Amy was excellent.   She was a life saver.   Being that we were coming from Jersey, she allowed us to have items shipped to her.   Enjoyed working with her.  Very professional.  John and Veronica S., North Brunswick, NJ

Excellent ongoing communication.  Robert and Astrid D., Ft. Lauderdale, FL